LiveMansion.com - a creative community

Friday, September 10, 2010
         
email address:  password:

   
Main Menu
 
LM Movie Reviews
The Golden Compass
Dec 10, 2007

Originally Posted on LiveMansion.com
Review By:  Jordan Michael


Promoting a film these days takes more than a flashy trailer and a plug from Leno; You've gotta have media hype, or what I like to call "extracurricular marketing." Perhaps your lead actors are rumored to be drinking, or dating, or drugging. Those are all great angles. Even better, your film could find itself in the middle of the "Big C"... Controversy. Which brings me to this weeks over-hyped feature, "The Golden Compass."


Based on a novel that you and I have never read, The Golden Compass is the story of Lyra Belacqua (Dakota Blue Richards), a young girl faced with modest task of saving her world from tyranny and oppression. Armed with nothing more than a pat on the back, and a "alethiometer," a compass device that can answer any question put to it, Lyra's journey begins...IMMEDIATELY.  In fact, if you miss the first 2 minutes of the film, you won't have a clue what's going on. None-the-less, from what I gathered during this initial info force-feeding, it goes something like this:  In an alterante universe there exist a parallel earth in which talking polar bears rule the icy north, witches rule the sky, and where human souls manifest themselves as creature companions called “daemons.” However, in this magical realm there also exists a ruling party called the Magisterium, a heartless organization, hell-bent on authority and blind conformity, that uses fear and the suppression of free-will to retain it's power.


Got it?

Me neither.

Anyways, in an last ditch effort to save their world from the Vatican-like Magisterium (and their ruthless plan to do away with daemons) various clans unite and resist. Ultimately "The Golden Compass" proves to be an ambitious film that crumples under it's own weight. This is not to say that the film is a complete failure; the scenery is impressive, the action sequences are memorable, and Nicole Kidman is perfectly cast as the dashing – yet diabolical – Mrs. Coulter.  But as for the rest of the cast, such as Daniel Craig (Casino Royale), and Sam Elliot (Tombstone), they are, well...good enough. 

Sadly, for all its hype and high-definition "The Golden Compass" lacks the most vital element of all: enchantment. I mean, lets face it, in today's world no one is going to knocked off their feet by special effects and an epic score. To be great, a movie needs to be unique. It needs to be visionary. This movie is neither. 

I recommend this movie to those of you who enjoy eating popcorn, paying too much for candy, and listening to polar bears talk. But, to all you atheist out there: save your money. Because it's not so much that "The Golden Compass" is anti-god...it's just anti-good. 



Sponsor
 
Movie Review Archive
Iron Man
Posted: 05/09/2008
Review By: Justine Stone
Read the review »
Be Kind Rewind
Posted: 02/26/2008
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Cloverfield
Posted: 01/24/2008
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Sweeney Todd: The Demaon Barber of Fleet Street
Posted: 01/10/2008
Review By: Justin Stone
Read the review »
The Diving Bell And The Butterfly
Posted: 12/20/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
The Golden Compass
Posted: 12/12/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Beowulf
Posted: 11/21/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
P2
Posted: 11/12/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
No Country For Old Men
Posted: 11/12/2007
Review By: Jordan Tarquin
Read the review »
Dan in Real Life
Posted: 11/14/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
American Gangster
Posted: 11/06/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Bee Movie
Posted: 11/05/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
Martian Child
Posted: 11/05/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
30 Days of Night
Posted: 10/22/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
Rendition
Posted: 10/22/2007
Review By: Gene DeWitt
Read the review »
The Comebacks
Posted: 10/22/2007
Review By: Jordan Tarquin
Read the review »
Elizabeth: The Golden Age
Posted: 10/15/2007
Review By: Jordan Tarquin
Read the review »
Lars and the Real Girl
Posted: 10/15/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
We Own the Night
Posted: 10/15/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Why Did I Get Married
Posted: 10/15/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
Kurt Cobain: About a Son
Posted: 10/11/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Michael Clayton
Posted: 10/08/2007
Review By: Gene DeWitt
Read the review »
The Heartbreak Kid
Posted: 10/08/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
King of California
Posted: 10/02/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
The Darjeeling Limited
Posted: 10/02/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
Into the Wild
Posted: 10/15/2007
Review By: Gene DeWitt
Read the review »
In the Valley of Elah
Posted: 09/24/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
Resident Evil: Extinction
Posted: 09/24/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford
Posted: 09/24/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
Across the Universe
Posted: 09/20/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Mr. Woodcock
Posted: 09/17/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
The Brave One
Posted: 09/17/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
Eastern Promises
Posted: 09/17/2007
Review By: Gene DeWitt
Read the review »
3:10 to Yuma
Posted: 09/10/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Shoot em Up
Posted: 09/10/2007
Review By: Gene DeWitt
Read the review »
In the Shadow of the Moon
Posted: 09/10/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
I Want Someone to Eat Cheese With
Posted: 09/10/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
Hatchet
Posted: 09/10/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
Balls of Fury
Posted: 09/06/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Halloween
Posted: 09/06/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
Daddy Day Camp
Posted: 09/06/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
The Nanny Diaries
Posted: 08/27/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
Resurrecting the Champ
Posted: 08/27/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Daft Punk: Electroma
Posted: 08/27/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
Superbad
Posted: 08/21/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
King of Kong
Posted: 08/21/2007
Review By: Gene DeWitt
Read the review »
The Invasion
Posted: 08/21/2007
Review By: Canon Avery
Read the review »
11th Hour
Posted: 12/05/2007
Review By: Jordan Michael
Read the review »
Rush Hour 3
Posted: 08/15/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
Skinwalkers
Posted: 08/15/2007
Review By: Bode Yatsen
Read the review »
LM Search
screen name:
email address:
between the ages of:
and
show only members with photos:
 
Box Office Top 10
1
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

National Treasure: Book of Secrets
Weekend gross: $35.6M

2
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

Alvin and the Chipmunks
Weekend gross: $30M

 

3
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

I Am Legend
Weekend gross: $27.5M

 

4
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

Charlie Wilson's War
Weekend gross: $11.8M

5
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

Juno
Weekend gross
: $10.3M

6
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

Alien vs. Predator: Requiem
Weekend gross
: $10.05M

7
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

The Water Horse: Legend of the Deep
Weekend gross
: $9.2M

8
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

P.S. I Love You
Weekend gross
: $9.1M

9
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Weekend gross
: $8M

 

10
/life/_photos/2006/10/15/grudge-thumb.jpg

Enchanted
Weekend gross
: $6.5M

 
Top 10 Selling DVD's
 
Movie Trailers

Movie News
Lane, Cross join 'Stand Up To Cancer' telethon (AP)

FILE - In this Tuesday, Sept. 30, 2008  file photo, actress Diane Lane poses on the red carpet prior to the German premiere of the movie the 'Nights In Rodanthe' in Berlin. Diane Lane, Marcia Cross and Mark Harmon are set to join more than 100 celebrities for Friday, Sept. 10, 2010 'Stand Up To Cancer' telethon. (AP Photo/Miguel Villagran, File)AP - Diane Lane, Marcia Cross and Mark Harmon are set to join more than 100 celebrities for Friday's "Stand Up To Cancer" telethon.


'Runway' stars, Siriano kick off NY Fashion Week (AP)

Fashion from Christian Siriano Spring 2011 collection is modeled Thursday Sept. 9, 2010, during Fashion Week in New York. (AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews)AP - New York Fashion Week brought its cutting-edge style uptown on Thursday, opening its spring-collection previews in a new location at Lincoln Center.


Box Office Preview: 'Evil' to scare away others (AP)
AP - It's going to be a particularly evil weekend as Sony-Screen Gems' "Resident Evil: Afterlife 3D" goes for the best debut in the history of the horror franchise with a 3-D powered gross that is likely to top the $25 million mark.
Lane, Cross join 'Stand Up To Cancer' telethon (omg!)
omg! - AP - Diane Lane, Marcia Cross and Mark Harmon are set to join more than 100 celebrities for Friday's "Stand Up To Cancer" telethon.
Jimmy Johnson becomes `Survivor' celebrity (AP)
AP - Jimmy Johnson has become a "Survivor" celebrity, even though he has yet to appear on the show.
Woman accusing Vince Neil of grabbing her in Vegas (AP)

FILE - In this Aug. 5, 2010 file photo, singer Vince Neil performs at the Wacken Open Air Festival in Wacken, Schleswig Holstein, northern Germany. (AP Photo/Axel Heimken)AP - Police were investigating a complaint by a woman who claimed Motley Crue singer Vince Neil grabbed her arms in an elevator at the Las Vegas Hilton, but a hotel executive said Thursday surveillance video showed the allegation was not true.


Representatives say Glenn Beck to donate fee (AP)

FILE - In this June 29, 2010 file photo, former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin speaks to the crowd at the P.U.R.E. Ministries in Duluth, Ga. It's not a real word, but that hasn't stopped 'refudiate' from becoming Merriam-Webster's 2010 'Word of the Summer.'  The publishing company says Sarah Palin's pseudo-word was the most-often searched by users of its online dictionary, The Associated Press reports on Tuesday, Sept. 7, 2010. The former Alaska governor used it twice in July: once on a news show and later on Twitter, in place of refute or repudiate. (AP Photo/Erik S. Lesser, File)AP - Representatives say Glenn Beck will donate his speaking fee from his upcoming appearance with Sarah Palin in Anchorage.


Lane, Cross join 'Stand Up To Cancer' telethon (AP)

FILE - In this Tuesday, Sept. 30, 2008  file photo, actress Diane Lane poses on the red carpet prior to the German premiere of the movie the 'Nights In Rodanthe' in Berlin. Diane Lane, Marcia Cross and Mark Harmon are set to join more than 100 celebrities for Friday, Sept. 10, 2010 'Stand Up To Cancer' telethon. (AP Photo/Miguel Villagran, File)AP - Diane Lane, Marcia Cross and Mark Harmon are set to join more than 100 celebrities for Friday's "Stand Up To Cancer" telethon.


 
Movie Message Board
Live Mansion Reopens!!!!!!!!!
0 comments | posted by early
posted: 35 days, 6 hours, 44 minutes ago
they should change the name of...
2 comments | posted by CraigScribner
posted: 232 days, 8 hours, 6 minutes ago
Make Some Noise!!!...
6 comments | posted by ljk
posted: 374 days, 16 hours, 38 minutes ago
Update on the Movie
1 comments | posted by early
posted: 403 days, 18 hours, 23 minutes ago
what do i do with all these id...
6 comments | posted by Ameliza
posted: 632 days, 8 hours, 6 minutes ago
Hidden Talents?
1 comments | posted by Ameliza
posted: 632 days, 8 hours, 12 minutes ago
Information
6 comments | posted by Information
posted: 785 days, 15 hours, 55 minutes ago